The Top 8 Pizza Near Four Seasons at The Surf Club
-
Rank 1. La Natural
Wood-fired Pizza
This Little River pizza spot earned a Michelin Bib Gourmand, and the crowds have taken note, so showing up without a plan is a gamble. It's a dim, concrete-floored hangout where natural wine flows freely and wood-fired pies come out gorgeously charred with toppings you wouldn't expect on a pizza. The room feels like a party that got slightly out of hand in the best way, full of people who know exactly how cool they are.
- Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand
- Esquire 2021 · #16 · The Best New Restaurants in America
- Miami New Times 2025 · Best Restaurant (MiMo/Little River) · Best of Miami New Times
-
-
Rank 3. Lucali
Wood-fired Pizza
The Brooklyn original has a reputation that precedes it, and this South Beach outpost earns its share of the legend. It's a casual pizza spot with a wood-fired brick oven and an outdoor patio draped in greenery that looks almost too good to be real. The crowd is an only-in-Miami mix of locals who've been coming for years and tourists who read about it on the plane. Go for the 18-inch pie with a blistered, paper-thin crust.
-
Tucked into the ground floor of an office building steps from Lincoln Road, this South Beach pizzeria is easy to walk past and hard to forget. The thin-crust pies are the move, made from imported Italian flour and slow-proofed for two days, which gives the dough a depth most slice joints never bother with. The crowd skews local and loyal, the kind who already know what they're ordering before they sit down.
-
Rank 5. La Leggenda Pizzeria
Neapolitan Pizza
-
- 50 Top Pizza 2025 · #6 · 50 Top Pizza Slice USA
- Eater 38 Essential Restaurants in Miami
- Miami New Times 2024 · Best Pizza · Best of Miami New Times
-
Rank 7. Heritage
New York-style Pizza
A Bib Gourmand pizza spot in Flagler Village that takes the New York-style pie somewhere more interesting than your usual corner slice. The toppings here are genuinely creative without being weird for the sake of it, and the crust holds up to all of it. Dessert is not an afterthought, which surprises most people. The crowd is young and neighborhood-casual, the kind of place where everyone looks like they live nearby and already know what they're ordering.
- Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand
- Miami New Times 2023 · Best Restaurant (Fort Lauderdale) · Best of Miami New Times
-