The Brant

Three shingle-style houses clustered near Brant Point make up this boutique hotel, which belongs to the Salt Hotels group and holds a Michelin Key. The interiors skip the obligatory whaling-captain aesthetic most of the island leans on, going for something quieter and more rural in spirit. It sits close enough to the port and the main drag to be convenient, but far enough away that you won't hear other people's children.