-
A sea captain's house steps from Edgartown harbor, now a boutique hotel where the decor reads less "beach rental" and more "well-traveled person with good taste in velvet." Jewel tones, Eastern-inspired wallpapers, and original crown moldings share space without apologizing to each other. It's a small property, so the vibe is intimate rather than resort-y, which suits the neighborhood just fine.
One honor, in evidence:
The record strongest first
- Michelin Guide Selected Hotels
One number, weighted & current 74
How we score
Nearby in the record closest first
- The Sydney Stay · 74
- Faraway Martha's Vineyard Stay · 80
- The Edgartown Inn Stay · 74
- The Christopher Stay · 74
- The Richard Stay · 74
- Hob Knob Stay · 80
Something wrong with this entry? Tell us — closed, moved, miscategorized, we want to know.