The Cottage in the Wood

A black-and-white inn perched a thousand feet up Whinlatter Pass, with views across the conifer canopy to Skiddaw that make it hard to concentrate on dinner. This Michelin-starred restaurant-with-rooms runs a modern British tasting menu, and the team presents each course themselves, squirrels gathering at the conservatory windows throughout. The wine list leans natural, the service is warm rather than formal, and the potato bread apparently inspires requests for seconds.

Three honors, in evidence: