The Best Pizza Near Hotel Winters, by the Record
-
Rank 1. Croccante Pizza
Detroit-Style Pizza
Detroit-style pizza in Napa Valley is a mild act of defiance, and Croccante leans into it. The thick, airy dough goes soft in the middle and properly crunchy at the caramelized edges, with toppings piled on hot and generous. The menu rounds out with sandwiches, meat dishes, and salads, and weekends bring brunch. The bar corner is well stocked with wine, cocktails, and non-alcoholic options, which fits the neighborhood. Named among 50 Top Pizza USA's Excellent Pizzerias.
-
Rank 2. Majka
Pizza
Naturally leavened crusts are the foundation at this neighborhood pizzeria and bakery, where toppings rotate with the season and the menu changes fast enough to keep regulars guessing. The pies lean ingredient-driven rather than maximalist, and the wine list skews natural with a serious grower Champagne section, which is not something you expect from a strip of 15th Street storefronts.
-
Rank 3. Slice House
Pizza
Four styles sit behind the glass at this casual slice shop from celebrity pizzaiolo Tony Gemignani: New York thin, Sicilian, grandma, and Detroit. You point, they reheat, you fold. The New York slices have that stiff-but-pliable thing that makes eating while standing feel like a skill. The grandma squares come thick, with ricotta pooled on top. Everything is straightforward, no reservations, no ambiance to speak of, just good pizza by the slice.
-
Rank 4. Pizzaleah
NY-Style Pizza
The crusts here crack audibly when you bite into them, which sounds like a small thing until you're at a table in Windsor wondering why most pizza doesn't do that. Pizzaleah is a NY-style slice shop where Leah Scurto handles the dough personally, and the brick oven leaves a char on the underside that keeps everything from going soft. The San Francisco Chronicle named it one of Sonoma County's best restaurants. Hot honey and Calabrian chile pies share the menu with the unironic classics.