The Best Pizza Near Psychic Pie, by the Record

1. San Francisco Chronicle #69 · Top 100 Restaurants in the Bay Area

Rectangular pizzas sold by the meal-size slice anchor the menu at this busy Cal-Italian bakery and kitchen on Highway One in Tomales, a natural pit stop for anyone driving or cycling the coast. The menu is tight, meatballs and salads alongside the pizza, but the bread is its own reason to pull over. The olive loaf, dense with Kalamata and green olives, travels well. The San Francisco Chronicle named it one of the Bay Area's best sandwich spots.

1. San Francisco Chronicle Best sandwich spots in the Bay Area
2. San Francisco Chronicle Best restaurants in Marin County: Sausalito, Novato and San Rafael

Vintage film posters and antique tools cover the walls, and the wood-fired pizzas at this Geyserville pizzeria fill the room within minutes of the doors opening. The house-cured meats and the blistered Neapolitan pies built around the team's own smoked salumi are the draw, though the back patio, a glass-roofed greenhouse reached through an alley that looks borrowed from an Italian hill town, is reason enough to linger.

1. Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant
2. San Francisco Chronicle Best restaurants in Sonoma County

The crusts here crack audibly when you bite into them, which sounds like a small thing until you're at a table in Windsor wondering why most pizza doesn't do that. Pizzaleah is a NY-style slice shop where Leah Scurto handles the dough personally, and the brick oven leaves a char on the underside that keeps everything from going soft. The San Francisco Chronicle named it one of Sonoma County's best restaurants. Hot honey and Calabrian chile pies share the menu with the unironic classics.

1. San Francisco Chronicle Best restaurants in Sonoma County

Wood is stacked floor to ceiling against the walls and under the counter, which tells you everything about the priorities here. Cafe Reyes is a wood-fired pizza shop in Point Reyes Station, the kind of barn-sized, unfussy room that makes sense after a morning on the coast. The pies are named after local landmarks, the crust has real char, and the whole operation gives day-trippers a very good reason to stop before the drive back.

1. Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant

Detroit-style pizza in Napa Valley is a mild act of defiance, and Croccante leans into it. The thick, airy dough goes soft in the middle and properly crunchy at the caramelized edges, with toppings piled on hot and generous. The menu rounds out with sandwiches, meat dishes, and salads, and weekends bring brunch. The bar corner is well stocked with wine, cocktails, and non-alcoholic options, which fits the neighborhood. Named among 50 Top Pizza USA's Excellent Pizzerias.

1. 50 Top Pizza 50 Top Pizza USA Excellent Pizzerias

Seven ovens, eleven styles of pizza, and one corner spot in North Beach that takes the whole argument about which regional pie is superior and simply refuses to pick a side. Tony Gemignani's pizzeria runs Neapolitan next to Detroit next to New Haven next to Roman, all under one roof, which is either heresy or the only sane position. It lands at number two on 50 Top Pizza USA and number ten in the world.

1. 50 Top Pizza #10 · 50 Top Pizza World
2. 50 Top Pizza #2 · 50 Top Pizza USA
3. Sunset Inspired Italian · Where to Eat and Drink

Bagels hang in metal racks draped with white sheets, a nod to the coin-operated laundry this place used to be. Now it's an all-day pizza and bagel shop on Balboa, mornings given over to coffee from Grand Coffee and a solid bagel lineup that runs from egg to rye, with schmears folded through green onion or spiked with Calabrian chiles. The San Francisco Chronicle named it among the top bagels in the Bay Area, and a Top 100 restaurant pick followed.

1. San Francisco Chronicle Best bagels in the San Francisco Bay Area
2. San Francisco Chronicle #85 · Top 100 Restaurants in the Bay Area
3. The Infatuation The 19 Best Pizza Places In San Francisco

The wood-burning oven is the heart of this Marina pizzeria, turning out Neapolitan-style pies with a smoky char while the open kitchen keeps the whole room warm and lively. The menu leans rustic Italian, pies and pastas shifting with the season, and the wine list ranges across regions most Italian restaurants ignore. Counter seats facing the oven are the ones to ask for. The Michelin Guide has given it a Bib Gourmand, and the room fills fast with families and regulars who booked ahead.

1. Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand

1. The Infatuation The 19 Best Pizza Places In San Francisco
2. The Infatuation The 25 Best Meals For Under $15 In SF
3. Eater The 38 Essential Restaurants in San Francisco

The flower-ringed patio on University Avenue is not accidental: this is Rose Pizzeria, and it commits to the bit. Thin, crispy pies here borrow from every regional tradition and answer to none of them, landing somewhere between Neapolitan char and California confidence. The Caesar with miso and Calabrian chiles is the kind of side dish that makes you forget you ordered pizza. A spot on 50 Top Pizza USA keeps the room lively most nights.

1. 50 Top Pizza 50 Top Pizza USA Excellent Pizzerias
2. San Francisco Chronicle Best restaurants for outdoor dining in the Bay Area
3. San Francisco Chronicle #27 · Top 100 Restaurants in the Bay Area

The dough does double duty here: the same flour-and-water base becomes both pizza and pasta, which is either a philosophy or a very good way to halve your mise en place. This North Beach pizzeria turns out thin-crust pies that lean Italian in spirit but drift Californian in practice, in a wood-warmed room that moves with easy efficiency. Save room for the spoon desserts, which the regulars treat as non-negotiable.

1. 50 Top Pizza 50 Top Pizza USA Excellent Pizzerias
2. The Infatuation The 19 Best Pizza Places In San Francisco

A worker-owned collective in the Gourmet Ghetto, Cheese Board bakes one vegetarian sourdough pizza per day, rotating with the seasons, and you either want it or you don't. You probably want it. The line wraps around the block most days, but it moves fast, and the green sauce, herby and quietly ferocious, is non-negotiable. Grab a slice, claim a parklet table, and settle into the reliably frenetic sidewalk energy Berkeley does so well.

1. San Francisco Chronicle Best vegetarian and vegan restaurants in the SF Bay Area
2. San Francisco Chronicle Best restaurants for outdoor dining in the Bay Area
3. San Francisco Chronicle Best Berkeley restaurants

1. The Infatuation The Hit List: New San Francisco Restaurants To Try Right Now
2. The Infatuation The 19 Best Pizza Places In San Francisco

1. Sunset California Classics · Where to Eat and Drink

1. The Infatuation The 19 Best Pizza Places In San Francisco
2. The Infatuation The 25 Best Restaurants In The Richmond