The Best Seafood Near Gordon's, by the Record
-
Rank 1. Ondine
Seafood
Views over West Sands beach set the tone for this seafood restaurant inside the restored Seaton House hotel in St Andrews. The kitchen leans classic, letting crab, lobster, and sole from nearby East Neuk fishing villages do the talking rather than burying them in technique. It made its name in Edinburgh over many years before the move coastwards, which in hindsight seems obvious: the seafood was always pointing in this direction.
-
Rank 2. Haar
Nordic Seafood
Haar sits at the edge of St Andrews with a Nordic-leaning seafood menu that keeps Arbroath smokies and smoked lobster in the conversation. The format runs from a fixed-price lunch to an evening tasting menu, and the kitchen's instinct is Scottish produce filtered through a wider, well-traveled palate. The team also run a cocktail bar and seafood shack nearby, which is handy when St Andrews fills up, as it tends to.
-
Paintings of the sea cover the walls at this small seafood bistro opposite Pittenweem harbour, which doubles as a gallery for local artists, so you might leave with dinner and a framed print. The blackboard lists what came in that day, langoustines and hake among the regulars, all built around East Neuk produce cooked without fuss. It has the feel of a place the village keeps quietly to itself.
-
A converted pub on the St Monans harbour front, where most tables look straight out over the water and a small terrace catches the summer light off the Firth of Forth. The cooking is modern and composed, the kind that leans on whatever the East Neuk coastline drops off nearby. A fixed-price lunch menu and an evening tasting menu keep things focused, which suits the room's quiet, unhurried pace just fine.
-
Rank 5. Fish Shop
Seafood
A wicker shoal hangs from the ceiling and photos of fishermen line the walls, which sets the tone for what this smart seafood restaurant in Ballater is about. Scottish produce does most of the talking, with dishes built to let the fish shine rather than bury it. The specials board is where the freshest catches land. It holds a Michelin Bib Gourmand, and the room is relaxed enough that nobody feels the need to perform about it.