Mentone

A barn-style pizza spot in Aptos with soft colors, dark green-framed doors, and a communal feel that makes the whole thing read like a California farmhouse that stumbled into Naples. The pies lean Italian in a specific, considered way, and the menu wanders pleasantly into fried sardines and prosciutto broth before circling back to where it belongs. The house-made pistachio ice cream is apparently non-negotiable. The Michelin Guide gave it a Bib Gourmand.

One honor, in evidence: