1. Sugar Hill Creamery

    Dessert

    A small-batch shop on Lenox Avenue where the ice cream names—"sweet socialism," "chairperson of the board"—announce themselves like inside jokes, each flavor a minor act of whimsy. The Madagascar chocolate and graham-cracker-blueberry combinations suggest a kitchen unafraid of specificity, which is its own kind of charm.

    The Infatuation
    The Best Ice Cream In NYC
    Eater
    Essential Ice Cream Shops in New York City
    Address
    184 Lenox Ave, New York, NY · Manhattan
    Online
    WebsiteInstagram
    On the Way What's Around

Recents

  • No recent searches yet.

Yumscore

This score is based on the awards it's won and sometimes its proximity to where you're located (if you're doing a location-based search).

    Stayscore

    This score is based on the awards it's won and sometimes its proximity to where you're located (if you're doing a location-based search).

      Doscore

      This score is based on the awards it's won and sometimes its proximity to where you're located (if you're doing a location-based search).

        Best Place Score

        The Best Place Score is the score we give to the place you're searching from, based on how cool we think the area around it is. If it seems unreasonably low, we probably just haven't added a representative amount of awards yet.