The Best Restaurants in Sag Harbor, by the Record

3 places in the record

The best restaurants in Sag Harbor, by the professional record: Wine Enthusiast and Eater have both weighed in, and their honors are what rank this list. The American Hotel comes out on top.

Departments

All
Restaurants 3
Tasting Menus
Pizza
Steakhouses
Seafood
Sushi
Barbecue
Bakeries
Bagel Shops
Dessert Shops
Breakfast
Wine Bars
Beer Bars
Pubs
Coffee Shops

Rank 1. The American Hotel

French New American
1. Wine Enthusiast The Wine Restaurant Hall of Fame
Awards
- Wine Enthusiast The Wine Restaurant Hall of Fame
Address

49 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY · Sag Harbor

Online

Website Instagram
On the Way What's Around
Rank 2. Lulu Kitchen & Bar
1. Eater Best Restaurants in the Hamptons
Awards
- Eater Best Restaurants in the Hamptons
Address

126 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY · Sag Harbor

Hours

Mon Noon–3:30 PM, 5:30 PM–10 PM

Reserve

Resy

Online

Website Instagram
On the Way What's Around
Rank 2. The Restaurant at Baron’s Cove
1. Eater Best Restaurants in the Hamptons
Awards
- Eater Best Restaurants in the Hamptons
Address

31 W Water St, Sag Harbor, NY · Sag Harbor

Online

Website Instagram
On the Way What's Around