The Best Places to Eat in Staten Island, by the Record
The best places to eat in Staten Island, by the professional record: The New York Times, The Infatuation, and Michelin Guide have all weighed in, and their honors are what rank this list. Shaw-Naé’s House comes out on top.
Lakruwana and Enoteca Maria hold the next two places. The New York Times shows up on more of this list than any other guide, with Michelin Guide next.
-
Rank 1. Shaw-Naé’s House
Southern
- The New York Times The Restaurant List
- The Infatuation #16 · The 25 Best Restaurants In NYC
- The New York Times #81 · The 100 Best Restaurants in New York City
-
Rank 2. Lakruwana
Sri Lankan Indian
Murals, sculptures, and flags cover every surface floor to ceiling, so you've found the place before you've read the sign. Lakruwana is a Sri Lankan restaurant on Staten Island where street food drives the menu, the room runs loud and colorful, and the owner works every table like it's a reunion. The New York Times put it on their 100 Best Restaurants in New York City list, which tracks for a room this unignorable.
- Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant
- The New York Times #93 · The 100 Best Restaurants in New York City
-
Rank 3. Enoteca Maria
Italian
The menu changes nightly because the cook changes nightly, a rotating cast of nonnas from around the world who each bring their own country's food to this tiny, always-packed Staten Island restaurant. One evening it's Paraguayan chicken soup with cornmeal dumplings; the next, a Japanese seaweed salad with yuzu. The phone rings constantly, the tables fill fast, and Joe Scaravella's little place near St. George Terminal runs entirely on grandmotherly authority.
-
Rank 3. Seppe Pizza Bar
Pizza
Waterfront light floods a sleek, airy pizza bar on Staten Island's Navy Pier, where the cocktail menu leans savory and spicy rather than cloying. The Morty pizza, a pistachio pesto base loaded with burrata and mortadella, is the kind of combination that sounds fussy until you taste it. Baked wings with a serious char and a cacio e pepe round out a menu built for sharing. The Michelin Guide has it listed.
-
Rank 5. Joe & Pat's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Staten Island Pizza
-