1. Café Carmellini

    Italian

    Andrew Carmellini's fine-dining return occupies the Fifth Avenue Hotel with sapphire velvet booths and an open kitchen turning out Mediterranean-leaning dishes. A crab mille-feuille of delicate wafers and sweet meat in Meyer lemon sauce, or scallops in coconut-turmeric broth, suggest a chef working in layers of restraint and indulgence at once.

    Forbes Travel Guide
    Forbes Recommended
    50 Best
    2025 · #39 · North America's 50 Best Restaurants
    Esquire
    2023 · The Best New Restaurants in America
    James Beard Awards
    2025 · Semifinalist · Best New Restaurant
    Michelin Guide
    Selected Restaurant
    The New York Times
    2024 · New York’s 14 Best New Restaurants
    Address
    250 5th Ave, New York, NY · Manhattan
    Reserve
    Resy
    Online
    Website
    On the Way What's Around

Recents

  • No recent searches yet.

Yumscore

This score is based on the awards it's won and sometimes its proximity to where you're located (if you're doing a location-based search).

    Stayscore

    This score is based on the awards it's won and sometimes its proximity to where you're located (if you're doing a location-based search).

      Doscore

      This score is based on the awards it's won and sometimes its proximity to where you're located (if you're doing a location-based search).

        Best Place Score

        The Best Place Score is the score we give to the place you're searching from, based on how cool we think the area around it is. If it seems unreasonably low, we probably just haven't added a representative amount of awards yet.