-
Cash only, no reservations, and a line down Henry Street most nights: Lucali has been a Carroll Gardens institution long enough that the wait has become part of the lore. It's a small, candle-lit pizza shop serving large pies and calzones, nothing more. The dough is soft and thin in the New York tradition, and the room is the kind of quietly charming that makes two hours feel reasonable.
One honor, in evidence:
The record strongest first
- 50 Top Pizza 50 Top Pizza USA Excellent Pizzerias
One number, weighted & current 66
How we scoreThe dishes from the writeups
- Pepperoni pie 50 Top Pizza
Nearby in the record closest first
- Bar Bruno Mexican Eat · 65
- Untable Thai Eat · 74
- Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain Dessert Eat · 73
- Bar Ferdinando Sicilian Eat · 65
- Café Spaghetti Modern Italian Eat · 71
- East One Coffee Roasters Eat · 65
- Defonte's Sandwich Shop Italian Eat · 65
- F&F Pizzeria Pizza Eat · 71
Something wrong with this entry? Tell us — closed, moved, miscategorized, we want to know.