Monday, August 31, 2026

The Best Restaurants in Water Mill, by the Record

2 places in the record

The best restaurants in Water Mill, by the professional record: Eater has weighed in, and their honors are what rank this list. Bistro Ete comes out on top.

Categories

  • All
  • Restaurants
  • Tasting Menus
  • Pizza
  • Steakhouses
  • Seafood
  • Sushi
  • Barbecue
  • Bakeries
  • Bagel Shops
  • Dessert Shops
  • Breakfast
  • Wine Bars
  • Beer Bars
  • Pubs
  • Coffee Shops

  1. Rank 1. Bistro Ete

    Coastal French

    Awards
    Address
    760 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY · Water Mill
    Online
    WebsiteInstagram
    On the Way What's Around

  2. Rank 1. Calissa

    Mediterranean

    Awards
    Address
    1020 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY · Water Mill
    Hours
    Mon 5 PM–10:30 PM
    Reserve
    SevenRooms
    Online
    WebsiteInstagram
    On the Way What's Around

Browse a location

Current Location

Cities within New York

Metros

Recents

  • No recent searches yet.

Eat Score

The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

    How we score →

    Drink Score

    The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

      How we score →

      Stay Score

      The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

        How we score →

        Do Score

        The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

          How we score →

          Best Place Score

          The Best Place Score rates the area around a point, not any one place. It runs on the scored places nearby: more good stuff within reach, higher score. If it looks low, we probably haven't found enough critics out here yet.