The Best Sushi in Scottsdale, by the Record
The best sushi in Scottsdale, by the professional record: Foodist Awards, Phoenix New Times, and James Beard Awards have all weighed in, and their honors are what rank this list. Uchi comes out on top.
Shinbay and CATCH hold the next two places. Phoenix New Times shows up on more of this list than any other guide, with Foodist Awards next.
-
Rank 1. Uchi
Japanese
Tyson Cole's Austin-born Japanese fine dining concept has colonized Old Town Scottsdale, and the food makes it hard to resent the expansion. The menu runs well past sashimi and nigiri into tempura, grilled meats, and crudo, and you can order à la carte, build a tasting menu with your server, or hand over full control with an omakase. The room runs on polished service and the kind of care that makes a chain feel like a local obsession.
- Foodist Awards 2025 · Winner · Top Sushi Restaurant
- Phoenix New Times 2024 · Best Place to Take a Foodie · Best of Phoenix
-
Rank 2. Shinbay
Japanese, Sushi
Thirteen seats arranged at an L-shaped bar set the scale here: this is a reservation-only omakase counter in Old Town Scottsdale, two seatings a night, no improvising. The chef behind it, Shinji Kurita, is a name Phoenicians say with a certain reverence. Courses run for about two hours, and the sake list includes a bottle priced like a used car, should the mood strike. A James Beard semifinalist for Outstanding Restaurant.
- James Beard Awards 2022 · Semifinalist · Outstanding Restaurant
- Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant
- Phoenix New Times 2024 · Best Japanese Restaurant · Best of Phoenix
-
Rank 3. CATCH
Sushi
A steak-and-sushi restaurant inside Scottsdale Fashion Square, which tells you exactly who the room is built for. The menu runs from raw fish and specialty rolls through wagyu and pasta, so you can arrive with shopping bags and leave with a bill to match. The herb-roasted branzino, served over lemon rice, has drawn particular attention from local critics. Not cheap, but the kitchen takes the food more seriously than the setting might suggest.
- Phoenix New Times The top 50 restaurants in Phoenix right now
- Phoenix New Times The 10 best new Phoenix restaurants of 2025
- Phoenix New Times The 12 best restaurants in Scottsdale
-
Rank 4. Hiro Sushi
Traditional Sushi