-
A few steps from Madison Square Park, this pizza shop has made a name for itself with a well-fermented dough that stays light enough to eat without regret. The round NY-style pies lean into garlic, while the square pepperoni comes out properly leavened and crisp underneath. The XXL mozzarella stick, served with marinara, is the kind of starter that settles the question of whether to order it immediately. 50 Top Pizza USA ranked it thirteenth in the country.
The awards strongest first
- 50 Top Pizza #13 · 50 Top Pizza USA
- 50 Top Pizza 2026 · One to Watch · 50 Top Pizza USA Special Awards
- The New York Times 2023 · 1 star · Restaurant Review
One number, weighted & current 73
How we scoreThe dishes from the writeups
-
XXL mozzarella schtick
“the XXL Mozzarella Schtick (a large mozzarella stick served with marinara sauce) showcase a delicious and straightforward cuisine”
50 Top Pizza, 2026 -
Classic NY round pizza
“Here you will find the Classic NY round pizza with its garlic aroma and the delicious Pepperoni square pie, well-leavened and flavorful.”
50 Top Pizza, 2026 -
Pepperoni square pie
“Here you will find the Classic NY round pizza with its garlic aroma and the delicious Pepperoni square pie, well-leavened and flavorful.”
50 Top Pizza, 2026 -
Couch potato
“everything else is original, including the Couch Potato, a reworking of a loaded baked potato”
The New York Times, 2023
Reviews
Sign in to write a review.
No reviews yet
Reviews never count toward the Eat Score.
The neighbors closest first
- SpringHill Suites by Marriott Midtown Manhattan Park Ave Stay · 81
- La Tête d’Or Steakhouse Eat · 86
- Upland Californian Eat · 83
- Audace Italian Eat · 70
- Bar Calico Drink · 80
- Eleven Madison Park Eat · 98
- Freehand New York Stay · 75
- The Clocktower British Eat · 19
Something wrong with this entry? Tell us. Closed, moved, miscategorized: we want to know.