-
A few steps from Madison Square Park, this pizza shop has made a name for itself with a well-fermented dough that stays light enough to eat without regret. The round NY-style pies lean into garlic, while the square pepperoni comes out properly leavened and crisp underneath. The XXL mozzarella stick, served with marinara, is the kind of starter that settles the question of whether to order it immediately. 50 Top Pizza USA ranked it thirteenth in the country.
Two honors, in evidence:
The record strongest first
- 50 Top Pizza #13 · 50 Top Pizza USA
- 50 Top Pizza 2026 · One to Watch · 50 Top Pizza USA Special Awards
One number, weighted & current 70
How we scoreThe dishes from the writeups
- XXL Mozzarella Schtick 50 Top Pizza
- Chicory salad 50 Top Pizza
- Classic NY round pizza 50 Top Pizza
- Pepperoni square pie 50 Top Pizza
Nearby in the record closest first
- Waldorf Astoria New York Stay · 74
- Peacock Alley Eat · 60
- Guerlain Wellness Spa at Waldorf Astoria New York Do · 89
- Lotte New York Palace Stay · 85
- The Towers at Lotte New York Palace Stay · 81
- The Grill American Eat · 84
- Fresco by Scotto Eat · 60
- Fasano Northern Italian Eat · 69
Something wrong with this entry? Tell us — closed, moved, miscategorized, we want to know.