-
There's no sign on Eldridge Street, just a faux tailor's shop window with a glowing "A" and a buzzer you'll wait at long enough to second-guess yourself. This is the cocktail bar that opened in the old Milk & Honey space after Sasha Petraske moved on, and it runs on the same no-menu, tell-us-what-you-like philosophy. North America's 50 Best Bars lists it, and the wait outside on any given night suggests people have read that list.
The awards strongest first
- Difford's Guide 5 stars · Difford's Guide
- The 50 #72 · The World's 50 Best Bars
- The 50 #37 · North America's 50 Best Bars
- James Beard Awards 2022 · Nominee · Outstanding Bar Program
- Time Out #3 · The 30 best bars in NYC right now
- The Infatuation The Best Cocktail Bars in NYC
- Spirited Awards 2026 · Regional Top 10 Honoree · Best U.S. Bar Team – U.S. East
One number, weighted & current 92
How we score
Reviews
Sign in to write a review.
No reviews yet
Reviews never count toward the Drink Score.
The neighbors closest first
- Milk and Honey New York Cocktail Bar Drink · 67
- Good Guy's Drink · 50
- Bistrot Ha Vietnamese Bistro Eat · 82
- Ha's Snack Bar Wine Bar Eat · 84
- Comal Mexican Eat · 80
- Double Chicken Please Cocktail Bar Drink · 96
- Dirt Candy Vegetarian American Eat · 91
- The Historic Blue Moon Hotel Stay · 81
Something wrong with this entry? Tell us. Closed, moved, miscategorized: we want to know.