The Best Pizza Near Papa's Tomato Pies, by the Record

1. NJ.com #55 · New Jersey’s 99 greatest restaurants, ranked

1. NJ.com #77 · New Jersey’s 99 greatest restaurants, ranked

A neon green peace sign marks the door on a narrow Fishtown lane, and inside what used to look like an auto repair shop, the room opens into light wood and clean lines, somewhere between a pizza bar and a Scandinavian chapel. The menu is short, the dough is organic, and the crust stays crisp and chewy to the last bite. Natural wines and snacks keep you busy while you wait. A Michelin Bib Gourmand.

1. 50 Top Pizza #64 · 50 Top Pizza World
2. 50 Top Pizza #16 · 50 Top Pizza USA
3. Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand

The coal-fired oven sits at the center of the room like the point it's trying to make, and the point is a New York-style pie with deep Italian roots cooked the way early immigrants did it, because wood was too expensive. This is a comfortable, full-service pizza spot with appetizers, a solid wine list, and a menu that ranges well past margherita territory. Ranked 31st on 50 Top Pizza USA.

1. 50 Top Pizza #31 · 50 Top Pizza USA

1. The New York Times The 25 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

The line wraps around the corner off Palumbo Park at any hour, which tells you what you need to know before you even smell the place. Angelo's is a cash-only, no-seating slice shop and cheesesteak counter in South Philly, meaning you'll be eating on a bench or a curb like everyone else. The Michelin Guide gave it a Bib Gourmand, which the sesame-seed hoagies loaded with Cooper Sharp do nothing to contradict.

1. Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand
2. The New York Times The 25 Best Restaurants in Philadelphia Right Now

1. The New York Times The Restaurant List
2. Eater The 38 Best Restaurants in Philadelphia

Wood-fired, naturally leavened sourdough pies in a snug Spruce Street spot where a heart-shaped lamp hangs overhead and wine bottles line the windows. Sally is a neighborhood pizza parlor that pulls in families, couples, and the natural-wine crowd in roughly equal measure. The thin crust holds its crispness under a full load of toppings, which in Philadelphia, where pizza opinions run deep, is not a small claim. The Michelin Guide gave it a Bib Gourmand.

1. Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand

Marc Vetri is a name Philadelphians say with some reverence, and this casual pizza spot carries the family flag across a few Pennsylvania locations. The wood-fired pies come round or by the meter, with a dough that stays light without making a fuss about it. The menu runs from straight Italian classics toward a few fusion detours, and the salads are more interesting than they have any obligation to be. A pizza kit to take home rounds things out nicely.

1. 50 Top Pizza 50 Top Pizza USA Excellent Pizzerias

1. The New York Times The 25 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

Six days a week it's a neighborhood bakery slinging coffee and doughnuts in South Philly. On Friday nights, The Bakery quietly pivots to "secret dinners," turning out a short, rotating menu of tall, square pizzas on soft, airy dough with a crackery undercarriage. Seats are few, the menu changes, and the whole operation feels more like eating at a friend's place than a restaurant. Arrive early, or just arrive flexible.

1. 50 Top Pizza 50 Top Pizza USA Excellent Pizzerias

A wall of bread greets you before you see a single pizza, which tells you everything about Dan Richer's priorities. This wood-fired pizzeria in Jersey City runs on long-fermentation dough and a sourcing philosophy that treats New Jersey farms as co-authors, not suppliers. The original dining room, once a theater, still has that weathered-plaster gravitas. Ranked third in the country by 50 Top Pizza, and a James Beard nominee.

1. 50 Top Pizza #69 · 50 Top Pizza World
2. 50 Top Pizza #3 · 50 Top Pizza USA
3. 50 Top Pizza 2026 · Performance of the Year · 50 Top Pizza USA Special Awards

1. The Infatuation Square Slice · 25 Iconic Dishes That Define New York
2. Vogue The 25 Best Restaurants in Brooklyn, According to Vogue Staff
3. The New York Times The 25 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

1. The New York Times The 25 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

Waterfront light floods a sleek, airy pizza bar on Staten Island's Navy Pier, where the cocktail menu leans savory and spicy rather than cloying. The Morty pizza, a pistachio pesto base loaded with burrata and mortadella, is the kind of combination that sounds fussy until you taste it. Baked wings with a serious char and a cacio e pepe round out a menu built for sharing. The Michelin Guide has it listed.

1. Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant

1. The New York Times The 25 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now
2. BagelUp #30 · The Definitive 30 Best Bagel Shops in New York City

1. Grub Street The 43 Best Restaurants in New York
2. The New York Times The 25 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

A backyard in Park Slope and a margherita built on proper ingredients make Brooklyn DOP an easy neighborhood slice shop to fall into. The dough is treated with care, the format stays classic New York, and the beverage list is calibrated accordingly. The orange olive oil cake quietly outperforms every other decision you'll make that afternoon. It landed at number six on the 50 Top Pizza Slice USA list, which checks out.

1. 50 Top Pizza #6 · 50 Top Pizza Slice USA

1. NJ.com #28 · New Jersey’s 99 greatest restaurants, ranked

Cash only, no reservations, and a line down Henry Street most nights: Lucali has been a Carroll Gardens institution long enough that the wait has become part of the lore. It's a small, candle-lit pizza shop serving large pies and calzones, nothing more. The dough is soft and thin in the New York tradition, and the room is the kind of quietly charming that makes two hours feel reasonable.

1. 50 Top Pizza 50 Top Pizza USA Excellent Pizzerias

The bar room here was once a pharmacy, and the old apothecary shelves now hold bottles of wine and spirits where the remedies used to be. It's a multi-floor pizza and pasta spot in Jersey City with a rooftop that looks back at the New York skyline you just escaped. The pizzas follow Italian tradition, the spaghetti has its fans, and the music keeps the whole thing moving at a pace that feels deliberately un-Manhattan.

1. 50 Top Pizza 50 Top Pizza USA Excellent Pizzerias

1. The New York Times The 25 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

1. The New York Times The 25 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now