The Best Seafood in Brooklyn, by the Record
The best seafood in Brooklyn, by the professional record: Esquire, Eater, and Michelin Guide have all weighed in, and their honors are what rank this list. Sailor comes out on top.
Theodora and Saint Julivert Fisherie hold the next two places. Michelin Guide shows up on more of this list than any other guide, with Eater next.
-
Rank 1. Sailor
Seafood
The line wrapping around the Fort Greene corner is not a glitch; it's just how things work at April Bloomfield's neighborhood seafood bistro, where eggs with celery salt and a roast chicken somehow outshine the obvious Instagram moment. The skylit room is bright and unhurried, the menu turns with the seasons, and lunch earns its own following with a burger that regulars treat as a state secret.
- Esquire The Best New Restaurants in America
- Eater The Best New Restaurants in America
- Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant
-
Rank 2. Theodora
Mediterranean Seafood
Wood smoke hangs in the air the moment you walk into this Fort Greene seafood restaurant, which should tell you something about how the kitchen operates. Chef Tomer Blechman anchors the menu around dry-aged fish and open-fire cooking, pulling from a Mediterranean pantry that keeps things interesting without announcing itself. The bar draws a crowd that clearly has opinions about natural wine, and the pita alone justifies showing up early.
- VinePair Food & Beverage Program of the Year · The Next Wave Awards
- Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant
- Time Out The 45 best restaurants in NYC right now
-
Rank 3. Saint Julivert Fisherie
Seafood
Squeezed into a narrow Clinton Street storefront, Saint Julivert is a coastal wine bar where seafood does most of the talking and the small-producer wine list does the listening. The kitchen runs on a coastal imagination that drifts from tempura squash to Ibérico pork without losing the thread. Cobble Hill regulars who know to book early fill the room most nights. The Michelin Guide has it on their list.
-
Rank 4. Zoli
Seafood
-
Rank 5. Randazzo's Clam Bar
Seafood