The Top 10 Tasting Menus Near Blue Hill at Stone Barns
-
Rank 1. Sushi Noz
Sushi
Two Michelin stars and a chef who treats every piece of nigiri like it might be his last. Sushi Noz is an intimate omakase counter on the Upper East Side, and it genuinely feels like you've been invited into someone's very serious, very beautiful home. The kimono-dressed staff bow you out at the end, which sounds theatrical but somehow just feels right. Book carefully, since specific dates and times matter here.
- AAA Four Diamonds
- Michelin Guide 2 Stars
- Vogue 2026 · A Definitive Guide to the Best Omakase in New York City
-
Rank 2. Sushi Sho
Omakase Sushi
Three Michelin stars and a no-photos policy, which tells you everything: this is an omakase counter where the point is to actually pay attention. The chef ages, cures, and even adjusts the seasoned rice to suit each piece of fish, which sounds obsessive until you taste it. The hinoki wood counter seats a handful of people who all look like they've been saving up for this, because they probably have.
- Michelin Guide 3 Stars
- Vogue 2026 · A Definitive Guide to the Best Omakase in New York City
- The New York Times 2026 · #11 · The 100 Best Restaurants in New York City
-
Rank 3. Jōji
Sushi
Tucked into the base of One Vanderbilt, this Michelin-starred omakase counter is a genuinely quiet room steps from Grand Central, which is either ironic or genius depending on how you feel about commuters. The fish comes largely from Tokyo's Toyosu Market, the rice is blended and vinegared with real care, and the luxury ingredients are plentiful enough to make your eyes water along with your wallet. Suits and serious sushi people, mostly.
- Michelin Guide 1 Star
- Vogue 2026 · A Definitive Guide to the Best Omakase in New York City
- Eater The Best Sushi Restaurants in Manhattan
-
Rank 4. Noz 17
Omakase Sushi
Seven seats, one cypress counter, and a Michelin star make Noz 17 one of the more quietly serious sushi omakase rooms in the city. The chef moves through the progression with real precision, letting the fish and rice do the talking while everyone else in the room does their best to look like they eat like this all the time. It's an intimate, unhurried experience that earns its price, starting around $195.
- Michelin Guide 1 Star
- Vogue 2026 · A Definitive Guide to the Best Omakase in New York City
- Eater The Best Sushi Restaurants in Manhattan
-
Rank 5. KOSAKA
Omakase Sushi
A Michelin-starred omakase tucked into the West Village, where the counter seats twelve and the mood is quiet enough that you can actually hear yourself think. The chef runs the room with real confidence, and the fish gets out of the way of itself, though you'll occasionally find a small, well-placed surprise underneath a slice. The crowd dresses for it, because you absolutely should too.
-
Rank 6. Yoshino
Sushi
A Michelin-starred omakase counter where the chef relocated from Japan specifically to open this, which already tells you something. The room is spare and precise, the kind of place where everyone leans forward and speaks quietly. Expect cooked courses that nod to French technique before moving into traditional Edomae nigiri. Serious sushi people in the room, zero casual drop-ins, and a reservation that takes some planning to land.
- Michelin Guide 1 Star
- Vogue 2026 · A Definitive Guide to the Best Omakase in New York City
- Eater The Best Sushi Restaurants in Manhattan
-
-
Rank 8. Icca
Omakase Sushi
Tucked behind a cocktail bar in Tribeca, this Michelin-starred omakase counter feels like somewhere you have to know about to find. The chef sources fish entirely from Japan and keeps the nigiri classic and restrained, but the courses around them show real range. The room is small, the pacing unhurried, and the crowd tends toward people who treat dinner as the actual plan for the evening, not a precursor to it.
-
Rank 9. Sushi Ouji
Omakase Sushi
- Vogue 2026 · A Definitive Guide to the Best Omakase in New York City
- The New York Times 2024 · Suma Katsuo Sashimi · Here Are Our Top New York Dishes
-