The Top 21 Seafood Near Blue Hill at Stone Barns
-
Rank 1. Le Bernardin
Seafood
Three Michelin stars and Eric Ripert at the helm: this is about as serious as seafood gets. Le Bernardin is old-school Midtown fine dining done without apology, the kind of room where diamond necklaces and pressed suits aren't ironic. The seafood-focused menu skips the mandatory tasting marathon, so you can order like an adult. The crowd has expense accounts or anniversaries; either way, everyone's on their best behavior.
-
Lots of restaurants claim farm-to-table, but Purdy's is literally on the farm, a white farmhouse with fields out the window and real roots in what shows up on the plate. They grow, smoke, and cure a good chunk of what they serve, so the menu tastes like it means it. The crowd skews weekend-escape New Yorkers who drove an hour to feel wholesome about lunch. Hit the farm shop next door before you leave.
-
Rank 3. AbuQir
Egyptian Seafood
- The New York Times 2026 · #17 · The 100 Best Restaurants in New York City
- Grub Street 2026 · The 40 Best Restaurants for Kids (and Parents!)
- Grub Street 2025 · The 43 Best Restaurants in New York
-
Rank 4. Varka Estiatorio
Mediterranean Seafood
-
Rank 5. Penny
Seafood
Penny is a sleek seafood bar in the Village where the vibe is marble counters, bottles of Champagne chilling on ice, and oysters that make you feel like a person of taste without trying too hard. The menu leans into pristine, well-sourced seafood dressed with enough flair to stay interesting. Most seats are walk-in only, so show up right when they open and look like you planned it all along.
- 50 Best #19 · North America's 50 Best Restaurants
- Food & Wine 2025 · The Top 15 US Restaurants
- Wine Enthusiast 2024 · Forward 50 Restaurants
-
Rank 6. César
Seafood
César Ramirez has two Michelin stars and a reputation for the kind of precision that makes other chefs quietly anxious. His sleek, grown-up tasting menu spot in Hudson Square is mostly built around world-class seafood, and the sauces alone are worth the trip. Counter seats let you watch the kitchen move, which it does fast. The crowd is dressed well and paying attention, the way people do when the bill reminds them this was a special occasion.
-
Rank 7. Hamido Seafood
Egyptian Seafood
-
Rank 8. Oceana
Modern Seafood
-
Rank 9. Smithereens
New England Seafood
A New England seafood joint gone slightly rogue, tucked below street level in the East Village where the lighting is low and the menu is almost entirely ocean. The crowd runs young and food-curious, squeezed into every corner of a room that feels like someone's very cool basement. The wine list leans bright whites, and the celery root float for dessert sounds like a dare but absolutely delivers.
- VinePair 2025 · Sommelier of the Year · The Next Wave Awards · Nikita Malhotra
- The Infatuation 2025 · #7 · The Top-Rated New Restaurants
- Punch 2025 · Best New Bartenders · Logan Rodriguez
-
Rank 10. Crevette
Spanish-French Seafood
Crevette is a lively, white-tablecloth seafood restaurant drawing inspiration from the Spanish and French coasts, and the room earns every inch of that description. The wide dining space buzzes with first-daters and groups who've already committed to the martini list, while the bar pulls its own crowd. The food is bright and confident without being fussy, and the desserts are genuinely worth saving room for.
- Artful Living 2025 · The Top 5 Most Stylish Restaurants in America
- Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant
-
Rank 11. Dame
Seafood
A tiny, charming seafood spot on MacDougal that started as a pop-up and earned itself a permanent address and a serious reservation problem. The room is cozy and blue-washed, packed with the kind of people who actually did their homework. The fish and chips, built around a beautiful piece of hake in lacy batter, is the reason everyone showed up. The wine list is organized by whether you'd rather drink like James Bond or Austin Powers, which tells you everything about the vibe.
-
- Eater 2026 · The Best Classic Restaurants in NYC
- Eater 2026 · The 38 Best Restaurants in New York City
- Eater 2026 · The Best Restaurants in Midtown
-
Rank 13. Cervo's
Iberian Seafood
Cervo's is a Bib Gourmand seafood spot on Canal Street that leans hard into the coastal flavors of Spain and Portugal, and somehow makes it feel effortless. The room is tight, loud, and tiled, packed with the kind of people who are definitely staying for one more round. Order fish, order anything fried, and let the kitchen do its thing. It's the sort of place that makes you wish you'd booked earlier.
- Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand
- Bon Appétit 2018 · America's Best New Restaurants
- The Infatuation #24 · The 25 Best Restaurants In NYC
-
Rank 14. Oceans
Seafood
Park Ave South is lousy with restaurants, but this seafood-focused fine dining spot earns a second look. The room is genuinely beautiful, anchored by a bar up front and a raw bar and sushi counter in the back, so you're basically watching your dinner get assembled. The cooking pulls from both coasts and several continents, and the crowd skews toward people who dressed up on purpose and are glad they did.
-
Rank 15. San Sabino
Italian-influenced Seafood
-
Rank 16. Sailor
Seafood
April Bloomfield is back, and Fort Greene is very happy about it. Sailor is a bright, skylit bistro where the menu is short, seasonal, and hits harder than it has any right to. The line wrapped around the block on a Tuesday tells you everything. Lunch draws the neighborhood regulars; dinner pulls in anyone who managed to snag a reservation. Simple food cooked with real conviction, from the roast chicken to the burger.
- Eater 2024 · The Best New Restaurants in America
- Esquire 2024 · The Best New Restaurants in America
- Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant
-
Rank 17. Zoli
Seafood
-
Rank 18. Theodora
Mediterranean Seafood
Wood smoke hits you the second you walk into this Fort Greene seafood spot, and that's basically the thesis statement. The team is serious about dry-aged fish and open-fire cooking, which sounds like a cooking-school project but tastes like a very good idea. The crowd skews creative-Brooklyn, probably has opinions about natural wine, and doesn't need to look at the menu. Go hungry, and let the fire do the talking.
- VinePair 2024 · Food & Beverage Program of the Year · The Next Wave Awards
- Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant
- Time Out 2026 · The 45 best restaurants in NYC right now
-
Rank 19. Saint Julivert
Seafood
This snug coastal wine bar on a quiet Clinton Hill block punches well above its weight, and the locals who've claimed their regular stools know it. The kitchen leans hard into seafood with a creative, globe-trotting sensibility that somehow always feels coherent. The wine list favors small producers and actually matches the food. Bring someone you want to impress without making it weird.
-
Rank 20. Quique Crudo
Seafood Cocktail Bar
-
Rank 21. Randazzo's Clam Bar
Seafood