Account

Welcome

Sign in to save places, build lists, and keep your score.

Search

The Best Places to Eat and Do in Sag Harbor

3 places ranked

The best places to eat and do in Sag Harbor, according to the experts: Wine Enthusiast and Eater have both weighed in, and their honors are what rank this list. The American Hotel comes out on top.

Read the New York Edition

Eat + Do, change section

Departments

A department belongs to one section, so choosing one narrows the list to it.

  • All
  • Restaurants
  • Tasting Menus
  • Pizza
  • Steakhouses
  • Seafood
  • Oyster Bars
  • Sushi
  • Kaiseki
  • Yakitori
  • Tempura
  • Barbecue
  • Noodle Shops
  • Ramen Shops
  • Bakeries
  • Patisseries
  • Boulangeries
  • Bagel Shops
  • Doughnut Shops
  • Dessert Shops
  • Ice Cream & Gelato
  • Breakfast
  • Delis
  • Diners
  • Burger Joints
  • Sandwich Shops
  • Taquerias
  • Food Trucks
  • Bistros
  • Brasseries
  • Trattorias
  • Osterias
  • Tapas Bars
  • Vegetarian
  • Vegan
  • Wine Bars
  • Beer Bars
  • Pubs
  • Gastropubs
  • Taverns
  • Izakayas
  • Coffee Shops
  • Cafés
  • Outdoors
  • Shopping
  • Activities
  • Museums
  • Amusement Parks
  • Venues
  • Landmarks
  • Clubs
  • Spas

  1. Rank 1. The American Hotel

    The awards

    Address
    49 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY · Sag Harbor
    Online
    WebsiteInstagram
    Save On the Way What's Around

  2. Rank 2. Lulu Kitchen & Bar

    The awards

    Address
    126 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY · Sag Harbor
    Hours

    Closed now, opens 11:30 AM

    Sunday 11:30 AM–3:30 PM, 5:30 PM–10 PM

    Reserve
    Resy
    Online
    WebsiteInstagram
    Save On the Way What's Around

  3. Rank 2. The Restaurant at Baron’s Cove

    The awards

    Address
    31 W Water St, Sag Harbor, NY · Sag Harbor
    Online
    WebsiteInstagram
    Save On the Way What's Around

Browse a location

Current Location

Cities within New York

Metros

Eat Score

The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

    How we score →

    Drink Score

    The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

      How we score →

      Stay Score

      Four fifths of the score is the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin Key outweighs a listicle. The last fifth is where it is: the ranked places to eat and things to do around it, and how safe the country is. When you sort by what's nearby, distance from you changes the order, never the score.

        How we score →

        Do Score

        The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

          How we score →

          Best Place Score

          The Best Place Score rates the area around a point, not any one place. The places are 60% of it: the best of what's within reach, weighed by distance. The setting is the other 40%: how life goes in that country (how people rate their own lives, how long and how well they live, how safe they are) and what it's like right there (the air, and the weather). If the score looks low, we probably haven't found enough critics out here yet.