Tuesday, September 1, 2026

The Top 100 Places to Eat Near Athletic Brewing Company










  1. Wooster Street is New Haven apizza territory, so opening a Neapolitan pizzeria here takes a certain nerve. The family behind Zeneli trained in Naples and planted that tradition right in the middle of the local institution's turf. Wood-fired, soft-crusted pies with San Marzano tomatoes and proper mozzarella sit alongside classic Italian dishes in a room that feels genuinely like someone's people are running it.





  2. New Haven-style pizza has its own rules: thin, coal-fired, slightly charred, and not quite like anything you'd get elsewhere. Modern Apizza has been holding down State Street forever, turning out red and white pies with a crust that blisters and snaps. The Italian Bomb, loaded with cold cuts and vegetables, is the order regulars argue about. A casual, loud, no-fuss pizzeria where the line out front is a feature, not a bug.
















  3. Rank 29. Allium Eatery

    Modern New American















  4. A converted farmhouse in North Salem with sweeping views of actual countryside, which somehow makes the tasting menu feel earned rather than theatrical. This is a Michelin-starred modern French fine dining room with very few tables, run by a husband-and-wife team whose roots are in the south of France. The cooking is precise and quietly confident, and dessert gets its own moment to shine. Esquire named the Vesper martini among the finest in America, which is a strange fact about a farmhouse, and a good one.




  5. Rank 46. Cenadou

    Modern French

    The name is Provençal for "dining room," which sets the tone pretty neatly for this modern French bistro tucked into the North Salem countryside. White walls, dark wood, royal blue chairs, and big windows full of trees give it the feel of somewhere you'd actually want to linger. The kitchen takes Provence-leaning classics and nudges them gently forward, finishing the baba au rhum tableside with a rum pour and Earl Grey whipped cream.


  6. Rank 47. The Inn at Pound Ridge

    Contemporary New American

    White clapboard, manicured gardens, and a valet line that reads the room before you even step inside. This is a fine dining destination in a Victorian inn north of the city, where Jean-Georges Vongerichten's kitchen sends out contemporary New American cooking with a country-weekend ease. The menu pulls from his greatest hits, reworked for the setting, which suits the crowd who drove out from Manhattan pretending they live like this.











  7. A white farmhouse with actual working fields out the window sets the scene at this North Salem seafood restaurant, where "farm to table" includes a smokehouse, a curing room, and a farm shop next door. The kitchen grows and preserves much of what it serves, down to the hot sauce and the carrot bread. Cocktails lean into the gardens too. A Michelin Selected restaurant that earns the pastoral postcard without winking at it.








  8. Freshly pulled radishes arrive with browned butter before you've looked at a menu, which tells you everything about what Dan Barber is doing at this two-Michelin-starred tasting room on a working farm in the Hudson Valley. The procession that follows is theatrical and farm-obsessed, rooted in whatever the land is doing right now. Crisped linens, fine crystal, and a meal that could end with a tower of milk desserts, because the farm started as a dairy.





  9. Rank 68. The American Hotel

    French New American


  10. Part restaurant, part charcuterie counter, Augustine's Salumeria is a relaxed modern Italian spot in Mamaroneck where the menu leans hard on Westchester farms and local fishermen. The kitchen turns out Italian-leaning dishes alongside nightly specials that change the calculation every time. The room feels like a neighborhood place that happens to cook with serious intention, which is a comfortable combination.


  11. Rank 70. Badageoni

    Georgian Eastern European

    Khachapuri, the boat-shaped bread stuffed with molten cheese and a raw egg yolk you stir together yourself, is reason enough to make the drive to this Georgian restaurant in Mount Kisco. The room is warm and unfussy, Edison bulbs over dark wood, and the menu reads like a gentle introduction to a cuisine most tables are encountering for the first time. Ground lamb kebabs wrapped in lavash show up at nearly every table.



  12. Awards
    Address
    239 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY · Hampton Bays
    Hours
    Tue 7:30 AM–11 AM, 11 AM–3 PM, 3 PM–5 PM, 5 PM–9 PM
    Reserve
    Resy
    Online
    WebsiteInstagram


  13. Rank 74. OKO

    Japanese

    The open kitchen anchors the room at this contemporary Asian restaurant in Rye, where the chef treats Japanese cuisine as a jumping-off point rather than a blueprint. Nigiri, handrolls, and tempura share the menu with hot dishes and the kind of creative small bites that make the omakase worth considering. The lofty-ceilinged space draws a lively local crowd, and the bar fills up early. Selected by the Michelin Guide.





  14. Rank 78. Osteria Padre Pio

    Campanian Italian

    Every table at this cozy Campanian trattoria in Westchester starts the same way: a wooden board arrives loaded with caponatina and house-made focaccia before you've ordered a thing. The chef runs a scratch kitchen rooted in southern Italy, with hearty portions and specials worth circling. Finish with the house limoncello and you'll understand why the regulars never really need a menu.


  15. The carved wooden panels and semi-private booths signal that this is not your average strip-mall Chinese restaurant, even if the exterior gives nothing away. A full-service Chinese dining room in Hartsdale drawing multigenerational families on weekend nights, it runs classics like garlic-pepper shrimp and slow-cooked Beijing duck with real kitchen discipline. The chef earned a James Beard semifinalist nod, and the Michelin Guide has taken notice too.



  16. Whitewashed brick printed with animal silhouettes, polished concrete floors, and an open kitchen loud enough to compete with the table next to you set the tone at this casual Southern restaurant in Pleasantville. The menu runs the expected classics, fried green tomatoes, cornbread, shrimp jambalaya, and a buttermilk chicken sandwich stacked with bacon and cheese. Come hungry and bring people; the place is built for a crowd.


  17. Rank 82. Raasa

    Indian

    Fine dining Indian in Elmsford, where the menu wanders through regional subcontinents with real intention. The bhel puri is a good opening move, balancing sweet, spicy, and tart the way a street snack should, and the lamb curry finds the same balance at a slower pace. Kulfi falooda does the dessert work, and the mango lassi is the kind of thing you order once and then every time after.


  18. Double-height ceilings and exposed wooden beams give this rustic-chic Italian café in Scarsdale a barn-that-got-good-taste feeling. The two long, narrow rooms fill up fast, and the bar anchors the whole thing without trying too hard. The kitchen leans into comfort, the kind of Italian café where the broth in the tortellini en brodo tastes like someone's been at it since morning. Good for a leisurely lunch or an easy dinner when the city feels far away.


  19. Rank 84. Duryea's Orient Point

    Waterfront Seafood


  20. Grilled dates stuffed with goat cheese and prosciutto sit on the menu alongside burgers and charcuterie, which tells you most of what you need to know about this Tarrytown gastropub. It doubles as a gourmet market, so the front is stocked with food from around the world and the back opens into exposed brick and antique odds and ends. The kitchen roams the Mediterranean, landing on hearty seafood and steaks.


  21. Midnight-blue leather banquettes and exposed brick set the tone at this New Rochelle Italian restaurant, where the long bar fills early with regulars who seem to know everyone. The kitchen splits its attention between old-school classics and something a little more current, and Mom's meatballs in marinara with a scoop of ricotta make a convincing case for the old school. Chatty and unpretentious, the kind of place that makes New York's suburbs feel worth the commute.






  22. Rank 91. El Verano

    Upscale Mexican




  23. Rank 94. Bistro Ete

    Coastal French


  24. Rank 95. Calissa

    Mediterranean



  25. Rank 97. Kanopi

    Portuguese Mediterranean





Recents

  • No recent searches yet.

Eat Score

The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

    How we score →

    Drink Score

    The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

      How we score →

      Stay Score

      The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

        How we score →

        Do Score

        The score comes from the awards it's won, weighted by who gave them: a Michelin star outweighs a listicle. When you sort by what's nearby, distance changes the order, never the score.

          How we score →

          Best Place Score

          The Best Place Score rates the area around a point, not any one place. It runs on the scored places nearby: more good stuff within reach, higher score. If it looks low, we probably haven't found enough critics out here yet.