The Top 33 Places to Eat Near Hitchen's Barn
-
Rank 1. Hitchen's Barn
Modern British
A converted stone barn on the edge of Rutland that feels like someone's particularly well-organized farmhouse, this Modern British restaurant holds a Michelin Bib Gourmand and prices things accordingly. The seasonal menu changes enough to keep regulars coming back, and the front-of-house warmth is the unforced kind that's harder to pull off than it looks. The wine list matches the food's price point, which, in this economy, is its own gesture of goodwill.
-
Rank 2. Hambleton Hall
British
Rutland Water sits just outside the windows, which sets the tone before the food arrives. Hambleton Hall is a country house hotel dining room holding a Michelin star, where the kitchen has been run by the same chef since the early nineties, long enough to have a signature without trying. The cooking is classical but not frozen in amber, and the wine list runs to 400 bins, clearly someone's life's work.
-
A 16th-century farmhouse on a working 400-acre estate where the chef grew up, now earning a Michelin star for tasting menus built almost entirely from what his brother grows and raises next door. Exposed beams, brick, and the kind of provenance story that usually sounds like marketing but here is just geography. Drinks downstairs first, then up to the dining room, where the cooking is personal enough to riff on duck pancakes without embarrassment.
-
Rank 4. Olive Branch & Beech House
Traditional British
Stone walls, wooden beams, and a fire that earns its keep make this Rutland village pub exactly what it promises to be. The kitchen leans into hearty British classics, sourcing locally and growing vegetables in their own garden. Confit duck, fish and chips, the kind of food you want after a country walk. Beech House, just across the road, handles the overnight question for anyone not ready to leave Clipsham quite yet.
-
Rank 5. The Six Bells
British
-
Rank 6. Prévost @ Haycock Manor
Modern New American
-
A farmstead restaurant built with reclaimed materials from the very land it sits on, which tells you something about how the chef thinks. Jericho runs a surprise tasting menu, so the kitchen decides, and courses lean heavily on game, wood fire, and whatever the kitchen garden is doing that week. It's rural Leicestershire, deeply so, and the wine list follows the same logic: natural, organic, biodynamic.
-
A flyover and a shabby lane lead you to Sat Bains' two Michelin star tasting menu restaurant, which is either a statement of intent or a very good joke, probably both. Inside, 28 covers keep things intimate, and you can also book the four-seat Kitchen Bench in the pastry section or watch the savoury kitchen from the Tasting Room. The cooking shifts constantly, dish by dish, week by week, restless by design.
-
Rank 9. Chubby Castor
Modern British
The thatched roof and honey-stone exterior read as a classic English village pub, but the interior has gone a different direction, all smart lounge seating and glitzy finishes that ease into a linen-laid dining room. The cooking is Modern British rooted in time-honoured recipes, and the chef's experience shows in food that earns its place on proper tablecloths. A Michelin Selected restaurant tucked into the Cambridgeshire countryside, which is its own quiet kind of joke.
-
Rank 10. The Martins Arms
British
The carved Jacobean fireplace in the bar is reason enough to take a seat and stay awhile. This is a traditional country pub and dining room in the Nottinghamshire countryside, doing hearty British cooking without apology. The local Stilton is the thing to order: Colston Bassett is one of only six places in the world licensed to make it, so skipping the cheese course here would be a genuine act of self-sabotage.
-
Rank 11. Hammer & Pincers
Modern British
An old water pump out back is all that remains of the village forge this place used to be. Now it's an intimate restaurant in rural Leicestershire, running a seasonally driven tasting menu of ambitious, layered dishes. The beef Wellington arrives whole and gets sliced tableside, which sounds fussy but lands as genuine theatre. Boutique rooms are available if you'd rather not navigate country lanes afterward.
-
A Neapolitan family runs this Italian restaurant out of a substantial Victorian building in an Anstey suburb, the contrast between the ornate exterior and the sleek, mildly glitzy interior being very much part of the charm. The open kitchen pass lets you watch the cooks, which pairs well with the kind of warm, unguarded service that makes a place feel like someone's actually glad you came.
-
Rank 13. alchemilla
Modern British
Vaulted red-brick arches from a Victorian carriage house give Alchemilla its bones, while a living wall and roof garden signal that the chef had other ideas. Alex Bond's Michelin-starred modern British cooking leans hard into contrast, pairing sweet, sour, and citrus in ways that feel intuitive rather than engineered. The wine list tilts natural and slightly esoteric, which fits the room perfectly.
-
Rank 14. The Reindeer
British
A village pub down a narrow country lane in Nottinghamshire, with a view over the local cricket pitch that does a lot of the decorating. The cooking is resolutely traditional, bangers and mash and Sunday roasts done with care, plus a weekly pie night whose fillings change to keep regulars guessing. The Michelin Guide awarded it a Bib Gourmand, which feels about right for a place this unfussy and this good at the basics.
-
Rank 15. Ibérico World Tapas
Mediterranean
The dining room sits in the vaulted basement of Nottingham's old city law courts, which does give a certain dramatic quality to ordering small plates. Ibérico is a tapas restaurant with a Michelin Bib Gourmand, and its menu roams well beyond Spain, pulling in yuzu and dukkah alongside the Mediterranean anchors. Four dishes a head is about right. The crowd tends toward people who've been before and already know what they're getting.
-
Rank 16. Kushi-Ya
Japanese
Tucked behind the arch of Enfield Chambers, this compact Japanese small-plates and skewers spot holds a Michelin Bib Gourmand. The charcoal grill does most of the talking, turning out skewers that smell like they mean it. No bookings, so the lunchtime crowd forms early and moves fast. A courtyard terrace softens the urgency once you're in. The kind of place where the bill arrives and you quietly do the math twice.
-
Rank 17. Piccalilli
Modern British
Down an alley and up a stairs in central Nottingham, Piccalilli is a small-plates spot tucked inside a period building with exposed brick, heavy timbers, and dried flowers overhead. The kind of room that makes you feel you've found something. Three or four plates per person is the move, and the cooking keeps flavours familiar enough to trust while doing something considered with them. The wine list is short and fairly priced. A Michelin Bib Gourmand.
-
Rank 18. Raymond's
Modern British
Fish crackling lands first, a snack that functions as a mission statement for the meal ahead. Raymond's is a sharing-plates spot in Nottingham's Lace Market, the kind of room with counter seats, moody lighting, and a wine list heavy on by-the-glass options, as if someone sat down and ticked every box on the modern restaurant checklist. The crowd seems entirely unbothered by that, and honestly, so will you.
-
A thatched-roof country pub on the Great River Ouse, The Sun has the kind of postcard exterior that makes you wonder if the food can possibly keep up. It does. The kitchen runs its own farm, so "local ingredients" isn't just menu copywriting here. The bar hatch turns out goat curry and fritto misto alongside pints, while the seasonal tasting menu leans into beef shin, smoked trout, and whatever the farm is doing that week.
-
Rank 20. Plough at Bolnhurst
Modern British
-
A former silk mill canteen beside a weir on the River Derwent, this modern brasserie has the kind of setting that does half the work. Ask for a window table upstairs or a spot on the narrow terrace and watch the water. The menu ranges wide, from wood-fired plates and pasta through to steaks, including a tomahawk built for two, so the table tends to last a while.
-
Rank 22. The Cross
Contemporary British Pub
The dining room here was once a schoolroom, and the hand bell wall lamps haven't let anyone forget it. This Michelin-starred gastropub in a restored Grade II listed inn does serious British cooking, the kind that follows the seasons closely and sources with equal care. The back room looks straight onto the kitchen pass if you want the theatre. The tasting menu is how the kitchen makes its fullest argument.
-
Dinner here begins with a walk through a restored Victorian kitchen garden, which turns out to be less preamble and more the whole point. Grace & Savour is a fine dining restaurant built into the walled garden of a country estate, with a long tasting menu shaped by what the soil is actually producing that week. A Michelin star and a spot on the National Restaurant Awards list. Foraging and preservation do a lot of the work on the plate.
-
Rank 24. Upstairs by Tom Shepherd
Modern British
A tasting menu restaurant sitting above a jewellery shop in the middle of Lichfield, which is either the most unexpected address in the Midlands or a perfectly on-brand piece of theatre. Tom Shepherd holds a Michelin star, Staffordshire's first, and runs tight, unfussy modern British menus where each dish lands on two or three elements and earns every one of them. The room is 36 covers, warm, unhurried, and genuinely hard to book.
-
A pub whose back garden is so large it hosts its own Oktoberfest, sausage toss included. Inside, The Black Pug is a warren of cosy rooms; outside, there's covered seating, an outdoor bar, and enough room for a grumble of actual pugs, which is both the collective noun and, on any given weekend, an accurate headcount. Pizza Monday, Taco Tuesday, and free kids' meals on Friday keep the locals cycling through. Star Pub of the Year at the Great British Pub Awards 2025.
-
Rank 26. The Two Pigs
Modern British
The name changed from the Red Lion to The Two Pigs in 2023, and so did pretty much everything else. It's a gastropub in a Staffordshire village, doing modern pub classics with produce from local farmers and a micro-farm next door. Weekend brunches, Sunday roasts, seasonal cocktails, and bar snacks running all day give the place an all-hours, good-time quality that most gastropubs only manage for dinner service.
-
Rank 27. The Two Pigs
British
A snug bar, a slightly more formal dining room, and a terrace for when England briefly cooperates: this is a country pub doing what the form asks, and doing it with evident pleasure. The menu runs classic British, from Welsh rarebit through smoked haddock fishcake to pork schnitzel, and the trifle has a reputation. The same owner runs The Boat in Lichfield, so the hospitality instincts are well exercised.
-
Rank 28. The Warwick
Modern British
Wood-panelled walls and a garden terrace inside a part-Edwardian manor make the setting feel like a prop from a very tasteful period drama. The Warwick is a country house dining room that leans into the produce rather than the pomp, with a seasonal menu that keeps its focus firmly on what's growing nearby. On a warm evening, the terrace does most of the convincing before the food even arrives.
-
Rank 29. Kynd
Contemporary British
Coal smoke and kitchen garden vegetables set the tone at this contemporary British restaurant tucked into an old furnace house on the Hampton Manor estate. It's the more relaxed sibling to the estate's fine-dining room, with open-fire cooking and produce pulled from the walled garden just outside. The wine list leans natural, biodynamic, and orange. In summer, the former greenhouse opens with its own terrace.
-
A small, unfussy restaurant on Warwick's market square, in a building that has been a tailor's shop and, later, a restaurant called Tailors, which explains the name. The chef cooks hearty, classically rooted dishes with a light sense of play, and the room runs with the easy warmth of two old friends who seem genuinely glad you showed up. The wine flights, carefully put together, are a good reason to hand over the choosing.
-
Rank 31. Lighthouse Restaurant
Modern British
A self-taught chef running an intimate Modern British restaurant in the Derbyshire countryside sounds like either a love story or a cautionary tale; here it's the former. The menu swings between a full tasting format and a shorter sharing menu on weekdays, with the kitchen leaning hard into seasonal cooking and the occasional Thai-inspired detour, like a coconut and chilli broth that earns its place on the table.
-
-
Rank 33. Dough & Brew
Sourdough Pizza
Sourdough pizza in a relaxed Warwick spot that leans more weekend-in-the-pub than Naples-by-the-book, and that's entirely the point. Dough & Brew is a casual pizzeria with a convivial streak, where the dough gets serious attention and the atmosphere stays loose. It doesn't chase the Neapolitan tradition; it runs its own Anglo-modern formula instead, which 50 Top Pizza Europe has noted among its excellent pizzerias.