The Best Pizza in Brooklyn

The line out the door on South 2nd is the most honest review you'll find. This Williamsburg slice shop has a counter, a few standing ledges, and pizza makers working in plain sight from dough to oven. The crust is thin, crisp, and taken seriously. 50 Top Pizza ranked it the top slice shop in the country, and the New York Times put it on their short list too. Order, pay, wait for your name, eat standing up. That's the whole deal.

1. 50 Top Pizza #74 · 50 Top Pizza World
2. 50 Top Pizza #1 · 50 Top Pizza Slice USA
3. The Infatuation #19 · The 25 Best Restaurants In NYC

A disco ball spins over the dining room at this Graham Avenue pizzeria, where the thin-crust pies share the bill with house pasta and focaccia made in the open kitchen. The Italian wine list runs to two pages of sparkling alone, which tells you something about the ambitions here. The Calabrian soppressata and hot honey on the Diavola have a following. Michelin has it in the guide.

1. Eater The Best New Restaurants in Brooklyn Right Now
2. Michelin Guide Selected Restaurant

The Sicilian square here comes sauce-on-top, which is either the detail that makes you understand everything about Brooklyn pizza or the one you'll spend a whole slice arguing about. L&B Spumoni Gardens is an old-school Gravesend pizzeria where the outdoor tables fill up on summer nights with people who clearly know to finish with the almond spumoni. The crunchy, charred corners have been the point since forever.

1. AAA Approved
2. The Infatuation Square Slice · 25 Iconic Dishes That Define New York
3. Vogue The 25 Best Restaurants in Brooklyn, According to Vogue Staff

The red door on Moore Street opens into a loud, wood-fired pizza shop that somehow became the definitive argument for Bushwick's whole self-image. It holds a Michelin Bib Gourmand, and the pies earn the pilgrimage: thin, blistered, unapologetically themselves. The room is industrial and a little ramshackle, the staff looks like they're in three different bands, and the wait can be long enough to reconsider your life choices. Order ahead and take a box home.

1. Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand
2. The New York Times The 22 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

A wood-fired pizza shop in a converted auto garage in Clinton Hill, with kitschy décor that somehow pulls it off. The team spent years in the Jean-Georges universe, and that background shows up in combinations you wouldn't expect a pizza joint to attempt, like the St. Louis, which lays Midwestern Provel cheese over pickled peppers and meat on a proper crust. The Michelin Guide gives it a Bib Gourmand, and the room fills up fast on weeknights.

1. Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand

The New Haven-style pies here are cooked to a serious crunch, with dough pressed thinner than the Connecticut purists would sanction and a tangy, oregano-heavy tomato sauce that makes a decent argument for staying in Brooklyn. Wheated is a Ditmas Park pizzeria with a full bar that also does bagels, so the menu has range. The New York Times put it on their best pizza in New York list, which is the kind of thing that fills a neighborhood spot fast.

1. The New York Times 2021 · Critic's Pick · Restaurant Review
2. The New York Times The 22 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now
3. BagelUp #30 · The Definitive 30 Best Bagel Shops in New York City

The slices here are slender, which is a statement in a borough where bigger is considered better. F&F is a slice shop in Carroll Gardens running a quiet argument for restraint: a careful sauce-to-cheese ratio, toppings used sparingly and only when they add something. The New York Times put it on their short list of the city's best pizza places, and Grub Street agreed. Come hungry but not starving, because the line moves at its own pace.

1. Grub Street The 43 Best Restaurants in New York
2. The New York Times The 22 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

1. AAA Three Diamonds

A backyard in Park Slope and a margherita built on proper ingredients make Brooklyn DOP an easy neighborhood slice shop to fall into. The dough is treated with care, the format stays classic New York, and the beverage list is calibrated accordingly. The orange olive oil cake quietly outperforms every other decision you'll make that afternoon. It landed at number six on the 50 Top Pizza Slice USA list, which checks out.

1. 50 Top Pizza #6 · 50 Top Pizza Slice USA

A Neapolitan pizzeria a short walk from Barclays Center, Pizza Secret lands at number 15 on 50 Top Pizza USA, which is not the kind of thing a slice shop does quietly. The dough is well-leavened and light, the kind that doesn't sit heavy, and the fried appetizers are worth ordering before the pie arrives. The room is renovated and family-friendly without feeling like a chain, and the service knows when to disappear.

1. 50 Top Pizza #15 · 50 Top Pizza USA
2. 50 Top Pizza 2026 · Best Fried Food · 50 Top Pizza USA Special Awards

Whole pies only, no exceptions, which has annoyed exactly the kind of person who deserves to be annoyed. Chrissy's is a slice-free NY-style pizza shop in Greenpoint where the chef spent pandemic years perfecting thin-crust pies in his apartment before graduating through pop-ups to a permanent counter. The New York Times put it on their best pizza in New York list, which is not a short list to land on.

1. The Infatuation #5 · NYC’s Best New Restaurants
2. The New York Times The 22 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

Sourdough Neapolitan pizza in a cozy Bushwick spot where the lighting is dim enough to feel intentional and the wine list is longer than the beer list, which tells you something about the room. The crust is light and genuinely digestible, as opposed to the kind that sits with you on the subway home. Ranked in the 50 Top Pizza USA, if that's the sort thing you track. The veranda is lovely until it isn't.

1. 50 Top Pizza #17 · 50 Top Pizza USA

1. The New York Times 2026 · 2 stars, Critic's Pick · Restaurant Review

You order at the door, grab a table, and the pizza shows up without ceremony, which is exactly the point at this Greenpoint slice shop. The dough is soft and light in the way Neapolitan purists get worked up about, and the toppings stay out of each other's way. The bruschetta with honey and ricotta is a small, sweet detour worth taking. Ranked 32nd on 50 Top Pizza USA, Salsa keeps things casual enough that nobody feels underdressed.

1. 50 Top Pizza #32 · 50 Top Pizza USA

1. AAA Approved

1. AAA Approved

Cash only, no reservations, and a line down Henry Street most nights: Lucali has been a Carroll Gardens institution long enough that the wait has become part of the lore. It's a small, candle-lit pizza shop serving large pies and calzones, nothing more. The dough is soft and thin in the New York tradition, and the room is the kind of quietly charming that makes two hours feel reasonable.

1. 50 Top Pizza 50 Top Pizza USA Excellent Pizzerias

1. The New York Times 2022 · Critic's Pick · Restaurant Review
2. The New York Times The 22 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

1. The New York Times The 22 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

1. The New York Times The 22 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

1. The New York Times The 22 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now

1. Roadbook The best restaurants in Greenpoint, New York

1. Eater The Best Places to Eat in Bed-Stuy Right Now